Arbitration Agreements Archives - Horst Legal Counsel https://www.horstcounsel.com/tag/arbitration-agreements/ Emerging Industries | Litigation | Intellectual Property | Corporate | California Thu, 29 Oct 2026 14:26:45 +0000 en-US hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=6.8.13 https://www.horstcounsel.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/12/cropped-favicon-32x32.png Arbitration Agreements Archives - Horst Legal Counsel https://www.horstcounsel.com/tag/arbitration-agreements/ 32 32 Your Mandatory Arbitration Agreement Leans on Federal Law More Than You Think https://www.horstcounsel.com/your-mandatory-arbitration-agreement-leans-on-federal-law-more-than-you-think/ Thu, 29 Oct 2026 14:26:45 +0000 https://www.horstcounsel.com/?p=1834 If you run a California business, there’s a good chance every new hire signs an arbitration agreement during onboarding. Most employers assume the only question is whether the agreement is well drafted. But a new decision shows that a separate question can decide everything: which arbitration law governs it. When the answer is California law instead of federal law, a ...

The post Your Mandatory Arbitration Agreement Leans on Federal Law More Than You Think appeared first on Horst Legal Counsel.

]]>
If you run a California business, there’s a good chance every new hire signs an arbitration agreement during onboarding. Most employers assume the only question is whether the agreement is well drafted. But a new decision shows that a separate question can decide everything: which arbitration law governs it. When the answer is California law instead of federal law, a mandatory arbitration agreement may never become enforceable at all.

The case is Molina v. Triumph Residential Services, Inc. (Cal. Ct. App., 2d Dist., Div. 4, No. B350252, Oct. 22, 2026). No published California opinion had answered this question before. Now one has.

Onboarding Paperwork Meets a Wage-and-Hour Class Action

Triumph Residential Services is a Los Angeles property management company that runs residential buildings across Southern California. It employed Tiffany Molina from about April 2023 to September 2024. Roughly two months after she left, she filed a class action (a single lawsuit on behalf of a group of similarly situated employees) alleging Labor Code wage-and-hour violations.

Triumph moved to compel arbitration, meaning it asked the court to send her individual claims to a private arbitrator and dismiss the class claims. Its vice president declared that Molina received the agreement with other documents as part of hiring and onboarding. The agreement itself recited that both sides signed “freely and voluntarily.” And Triumph made one choice that ended up deciding the case. It told the court that California law governed the agreement, not the Federal Arbitration Act (the federal statute that generally requires courts to enforce arbitration agreements).

A Safe Harbor That Only Covers Federal Arbitration

Labor Code section 432.6, which the Legislature added through Assembly Bill 51 in 2019, makes it illegal for an employer to require arbitration of Labor Code or FEHA (the Fair Employment and Housing Act, California’s main anti-discrimination statute) claims as a condition of employment. A violation is a misdemeanor. Still, the statute contains an unusual safe harbor, a carve-out for certain agreements. Subdivision (f) says nothing in the section invalidates an agreement “otherwise enforceable under the Federal Arbitration Act.”

The Legislature wrote that carve-out to avoid federal preemption (the doctrine that lets federal law override conflicting state law). It didn’t work. The Ninth Circuit later held that the FAA preempts section 432.6 where the FAA applies. For agreements the FAA covers, the result is odd: an employer can enforce an agreement that it broke the law to create.

Triumph argued that the same safe harbor protected it too. The court disagreed. The carve-out reaches only agreements enforceable under the FAA, and courts can’t write in exceptions the Legislature left out. Outside that safe harbor, California’s ordinary rule applies, and courts won’t enforce an illegal contract. The court also declined to follow several federal district court rulings that went the other way, because none of them grappled with why the Legislature limited the exception to the FAA.

Triumph’s Own Words Proved the Violation

The parties fought over who had to prove the agreement was a condition of employment. The court never resolved that fight, because Triumph had already proved it.

In its motion, Triumph said Molina was free to accept the agreement, try to negotiate out of it, or look for other employment. Read that list again. Sign or work somewhere else is the definition of a condition of employment. Negotiating your way out fares no better, since section 432.6 treats any requirement that an employee take affirmative action to keep her rights as a condition of employment. The court added that an employee who must bargain her way out might have to give something up in return, and the statute’s anti-retaliation provision forbids that too.

The “freely and voluntarily” recital didn’t help either. Triumph had a full round of supplemental briefing to offer evidence that employees could decline the agreement, and it offered none.

What This Means for Employers With Mandatory Arbitration Agreements

Start with the governing-law question. If your agreement doesn’t qualify under the FAA, or if your own counsel argues it doesn’t, a mandatory agreement may carry no force under Molina. The court expressly declined to decide when an agreement counts as “otherwise enforceable” under the FAA, so that analysis has to happen agreement by agreement and business by business.

Next, look at how your company actually delivers the agreement. Boilerplate saying the employee signed voluntarily won’t rescue an onboarding process that treats signing as mandatory. If employees genuinely can decline without consequence, document it, and make sure HR practice matches the paper.

Finally, watch what you say in court. Triumph’s motion papers supplied the evidence that defeated it. A defense theory that boils down to telling the employee she could have worked somewhere else now reads as an admission.

Bottom Line

Arbitration can still work for California employers. But Molina shows that the federal statute carries more weight than many employers realize, and that a mandatory agreement resting only on California law may not survive a challenge. Have counsel review both the agreement and the onboarding process that delivers it, before an employee’s lawyer does.

Horst Legal Counsel advises employers and employees on arbitration enforceability and employment disputes. If you want to know where your agreement stands after Molina, we’re glad to take a look. Contact us here.

The post Your Mandatory Arbitration Agreement Leans on Federal Law More Than You Think appeared first on Horst Legal Counsel.

]]>
Your Arbitration Agreement Might Not Do What You Think It Does https://www.horstcounsel.com/your-arbitration-agreement-might-not-do-what-you-think-it-does/ Thu, 30 Apr 2026 17:15:42 +0000 https://www.horstcounsel.com/?p=1398 If your company uses a standard employment arbitration agreement, the California Court of Appeal just handed you a reason to pull it out and read it carefully. Not because of a federal statute that’s been generating headlines. Because of California’s own unconscionability doctrine, applied with a level of specificity that should make any employer uncomfortable if the last time anyone ...

The post Your Arbitration Agreement Might Not Do What You Think It Does appeared first on Horst Legal Counsel.

]]>
If your company uses a standard employment arbitration agreement, the California Court of Appeal just handed you a reason to pull it out and read it carefully. Not because of a federal statute that’s been generating headlines. Because of California’s own unconscionability doctrine, applied with a level of specificity that should make any employer uncomfortable if the last time anyone reviewed that agreement was more than a few years ago.

The case is Stoker v. Blue Origin, LLC (Cal. Ct. App., 2d Dist., No. B344945, Apr. 24, 2026), and it does not require space-industry facts to be relevant to your business. It requires only that you be a California employer who hired someone, handed them a take-it-or-leave-it arbitration agreement as a condition of employment, and assumed the agreement would hold up.

The Facts That Got Blue Origin Here

Craig Stoker joined Blue Origin in August 2020 as a senior director of program management. Like most employees at large companies, he signed an arbitration agreement at the time of hire. By his account, a company recruiter told him the agreement contained standard terms, that everyone had to sign it, and that everyone always did. Blue Origin presented no evidence that any of the terms were negotiable.

Stoker was terminated in October 2022 after raising concerns about the company’s safety practices. He filed suit in November 2023, asserting claims for retaliation, sexual and gender discrimination and harassment, wrongful termination, and related employment claims. Blue Origin moved to compel arbitration. The trial court denied the motion, finding that the federal Ending Forced Arbitration of Sexual Assault and Sexual Harassment Act of 2021 (EFAA) applied to Stoker’s claims and blocked arbitration. Blue Origin appealed.

What the Court Actually Decided — and What It Deliberately Avoided

The Court of Appeal affirmed, but it took a different path than anyone expected. Rather than resolve the contested question of whether the EFAA applied to Stoker’s mixed-claim complaint, the court went straight to the arbitration agreement itself and found it unenforceable under California law. The EFAA question remains open. The unconscionability question is answered.

To understand why that matters, you need to understand what the court found wrong with the agreement. Not one thing. Four.

First, the agreement was overbroad. Its scope extended to “any and all claims, disputes, or controversies” between Stoker and Blue Origin, and “Blue Origin” was defined to include the parent company, subsidiaries, affiliates, successors, assigns, and all current and former officers, directors, employees, and agents. In the court’s view, that language swept in disputes far beyond the employment relationship. An arbitration agreement that captures virtually any conceivable claim against a sprawling corporate family is not a carefully scoped employment dispute resolution mechanism. It is a dragnet.

Second, the agreement lacked mutuality. The company carved out categories of claims it wanted to preserve while requiring the employee to arbitrate everything. One-sidedness in an adhesion contract is always a problem under California law, but when the employer’s carve-outs operate precisely to protect the employer’s most valuable interests while leaving the employee’s claims subject to arbitration, courts notice.

Third, and this one is striking, the agreement waived the right to a jury trial on claims that were not subject to arbitration. Read that again. For claims that the parties expressly agreed would not go to arbitration, the agreement still stripped the employee of the right to a jury. The court found no legitimate business justification for this. A jury trial waiver attached to non-arbitrable claims is simply the employer trying to have it both ways.

Fourth, the agreement’s representative action waiver swept in claims under the Private Attorneys General Act. Under California law, PAGA representative claims cannot be fully extinguished by individual agreement in this manner.

Any one of those defects, standing alone, might have been curable. Together, they were not. The agreement contained a severability clause, and Blue Origin argued the court should simply excise the bad parts and enforce the rest. The court declined. When the unconscionable provisions are pervasive and central to the agreement’s basic design, severance is not a repair mechanism. It is a reconstruction project the court is not obligated to undertake on the drafter’s behalf.

What Employers Should Take Away from This

The instinct when a case like this comes out is to look for the distinguishing fact, the thing that made this agreement uniquely problematic. Resist that instinct. The four defects the court identified in Blue Origin’s agreement are structural choices that appear in employer-drafted arbitration agreements across California every day. Overbroad scope, lack of mutuality, PAGA waivers, and jury trial waivers on non-arbitrable claims are not exotic provisions. They are common ones.

If your company’s arbitration agreement was drafted more than two or three years ago, it may predate a series of California appellate decisions, Stoker now among them, that have progressively tightened the standards for enforceability. An agreement that cleared judicial review under earlier precedent may have accumulated defects under newer case law. The appropriate response is not a one-sentence amendment. It is a full review against the current legal landscape.

For companies that genuinely value arbitration as a dispute resolution mechanism, and there are legitimate reasons to, Stoker is also a design roadmap. Scope the agreement to actual employment disputes. Build in real mutuality. Do not use the arbitration agreement as a vehicle for stripping employees of rights that California law does not permit them to waive. And understand that a severability clause does not insulate a poorly drafted agreement from complete invalidation when the problems run deep.

There is a separate issue that Stoker leaves unresolved: how California courts will apply the federal EFAA to cases where sexual harassment claims are alleged alongside other employment claims. That question will get answered in a future decision. When it does, the answer will matter significantly for employers defending mixed-claim complaints in the post-MeToo legislative environment. Watch for it.

Bottom Line

If your company uses an employment arbitration agreement, assume it has not been reviewed recently enough. Pull it out. Have counsel check it against Stoker and the decisions that preceded it. An agreement you cannot enforce in court is not a risk management tool. It is a false sense of security. Horst Legal Counsel works with employers and employees on arbitration enforceability and employment disputes. If you have questions about where your agreement stands, we are glad to take a look

The post Your Arbitration Agreement Might Not Do What You Think It Does appeared first on Horst Legal Counsel.

]]>