Arbitration Archives - Horst Legal Counsel https://www.horstcounsel.com/tag/arbitration/ Emerging Industries | Litigation | Intellectual Property | Corporate | California Sat, 21 Nov 2026 00:11:20 +0000 en-US hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=6.8.13 https://www.horstcounsel.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/12/cropped-favicon-32x32.png Arbitration Archives - Horst Legal Counsel https://www.horstcounsel.com/tag/arbitration/ 32 32 Gender and Pregnancy Harassment Claims Can Take an Entire Case Out of Your Arbitration Agreement https://www.horstcounsel.com/gender-and-pregnancy-harassment-claims-can-take-an-entire-case-out-of-your-arbitration-agreement/ Sat, 21 Nov 2026 00:11:20 +0000 https://www.horstcounsel.com/?p=1867 Plenty of California employers treat their employment arbitration agreement as a firewall. Every new hire signs it, and every dispute lands in a private forum, away from juries and public dockets. Since 2022, employers have known about one federal exception for sexual harassment, and many assumed it reached only the #MeToo cases: unwanted advances, lewd remarks, misconduct of a sexual ...

The post Gender and Pregnancy Harassment Claims Can Take an Entire Case Out of Your Arbitration Agreement appeared first on Horst Legal Counsel.

]]>
Plenty of California employers treat their employment arbitration agreement as a firewall. Every new hire signs it, and every dispute lands in a private forum, away from juries and public dockets. Since 2022, employers have known about one federal exception for sexual harassment, and many assumed it reached only the #MeToo cases: unwanted advances, lewd remarks, misconduct of a sexual nature. But the California Court of Appeal just read that exception far more broadly, and the fallout reaches every claim in the lawsuit.

When we wrote about Stoker v. Blue Origin earlier this year, we told employers to watch how California courts would apply the federal Ending Forced Arbitration of Sexual Assault and Sexual Harassment Act (EFAA), which lets a harassment plaintiff refuse arbitration even after signing a valid agreement. Doe v. The Maybourne Beverly Hills Operator, LLC (Cal. Ct. App., 2d Dist., No. B341400, Nov. 17, 2026) supplies a big part of the answer.

Two Maternity Leaves and No Room to Grow

Jane Doe managed guest reception at The Maybourne Beverly Hills, a luxury hotel, from 2015 until January 2024. In 2020 she signed an arbitration agreement covering any dispute related to her employment. According to her complaint, her treatment changed once she disclosed her first pregnancy. She heard she couldn’t be a career woman once she had children. The hotel never interviewed her for a director position and hired a man. In December 2023, a regional director told her that as a mother, her children would always come first, and suggested she stop asking for raises and look elsewhere.

When she pressed the issue, the HR director accused her of a sexual relationship with a coworker, a charge she says was false. The hotel suspended her without pay and fired her five days later. She sued for harassment, discrimination, retaliation, and wrongful termination. The hotel moved to compel arbitration (asked the court to send the case to the private forum). The trial court refused, and the Court of Appeal affirmed.

The Arbitration Exception Covers Harassment Because of Sex

The EFAA defines a covered dispute by reference to whatever law the plaintiff sues under. The hotel argued Congress meant only misconduct of a sexual nature. The court started with the statute’s words instead. When the text gives a clear answer, it doesn’t matter what kind of case legislators pictured.

Doe sued under FEHA, California’s Fair Employment and Housing Act. FEHA says outright that sexual harassment doesn’t require sexual desire, and it treats sex, gender, and pregnancy as interchangeable. So a hostile work environment claim (a claim that bias made the workplace abusive) built on gender or pregnancy counts as a sexual harassment dispute.

The hotel also argued that promotions and raises are management decisions, which support discrimination claims rather than harassment. Still, California law recognizes that a widespread pattern of biased decisions can send its own hostile message, and the court weighed Doe’s pattern alongside the comments.

Federal Pleading Rules Decide, and Doe Cleared the Toughest One

Courts disagree about how much a plaintiff must allege to trigger the EFAA. This court held that federal standards control, not California’s more forgiving pleading rules. The statute says federal law decides whether it applies, and the outcome shouldn’t turn on which courthouse the plaintiff picks. The court didn’t choose among the federal tests, because Doe’s complaint met the strictest one: plausibility, meaning enough facts to make the claim believable on its face. It noted that a divided Ninth Circuit panel adopted a looser test on November 10, but said that ruling doesn’t bind it.

Then came the payoff. Because Doe alleged a qualifying dispute, the trial court properly refused to send any part of the case to arbitration. Her discrimination, retaliation, and wrongful termination claims stay in court with the harassment claim.

What This Means for Your Arbitration Agreement

If you employ people in California, your arbitration agreement won’t keep a gender or pregnancy harassment case private once the employee plausibly pleads it, and under Doe the related claims stay in court too. Moving the case to federal court shouldn’t change the answer, since federal standards control in both places. Better drafting won’t fix it either, because Congress wrote the exception. The exposure lives in what your managers say and how your promotion decisions look over time.

For employees, the lesson runs the other way. Specific facts about comments and patterns, not labels, carried Doe out of arbitration.

Bottom Line

Arbitration still has real value for California employers. But it doesn’t reach harassment because of sex, and that category extends well beyond sexual misconduct. Review your agreement, then review the conduct it can’t protect you from. Horst Legal Counsel works with employers and employees on arbitration enforceability and employment disputes. If you want a read on where your company stands after Doe, we’re glad to talk it through. Contact us here.

The post Gender and Pregnancy Harassment Claims Can Take an Entire Case Out of Your Arbitration Agreement appeared first on Horst Legal Counsel.

]]>
One Word in Your Arbitration Severability Clause Can Keep a Class Action in Court https://www.horstcounsel.com/one-word-in-your-arbitration-severability-clause-can-keep-a-class-action-in-court/ Fri, 06 Nov 2026 22:29:48 +0000 https://www.horstcounsel.com/?p=1842 If your company’s online terms of service include an arbitration clause, there’s probably a backup plan in the fine print: an arbitration severability clause that tells a court what to do if part of the agreement fails. Most businesses assume that backup keeps everything else in arbitration. But a new California appellate decision shows how one word in it can ...

The post One Word in Your Arbitration Severability Clause Can Keep a Class Action in Court appeared first on Horst Legal Counsel.

]]>
If your company’s online terms of service include an arbitration clause, there’s probably a backup plan in the fine print: an arbitration severability clause that tells a court what to do if part of the agreement fails. Most businesses assume that backup keeps everything else in arbitration. But a new California appellate decision shows how one word in it can send a whole class action back to court.

The case is Bogguess v. Uber Technologies, Inc. (Cal. Ct. App., 1st Dist., Div. 5, No. A174376, Nov. 4, 2026). Uber had the U.S. Chamber of Commerce filing as amicus curiae (a non-party supporting one side). It still lost. The word that beat it was “claim.”

The Fare Dispute Behind the Appeal

Two riders filed a putative class action (a suit on behalf of a group the court hasn’t certified yet) under California’s Unfair Competition Law and False Advertising Law. They allege Uber advertises its upfront price as the price you’ll pay at the end of the ride, yet frequently charges more. They want the advertising stopped and repayment for every California rider who paid more than the advertised price over the past four years.

Uber moved to compel arbitration under its January 2023 terms, which barred riders from seeking any non-individual relief anywhere. Under McGill v. Citibank, though, a contract can’t strip consumers of the right to seek public injunctive relief (a court order stopping unlawful conduct to protect the public at large). Uber didn’t fight that rule. Instead, it argued the riders sought only private relief and, failing that, that the court should split the case between judge and arbitrator.

A Login Screen Doesn’t Make the Injunction Private

Uber said the injunction would help only existing users who had requested a ride. The court disagreed. Following a 2025 Coinbase decision, it treated creating an account as the online equivalent of walking into a store. It also rejected the argument that individualized, real-time quotes made the case different, writing that Uber “cannot evade consumer protection laws just because its allegedly deceptive scheme is complicated.”

How the Arbitration Severability Clause Backfired

Uber’s clause said that if the waiver failed, any “representative claims” subject to the unenforceable portion would proceed in court. Uber read “claim” as one request for a remedy, so only the public injunction would leave arbitration. The riders read it as an entire cause of action, which would keep both causes of action in court entirely.

The court found both readings reasonable, since “claim” has no single legal meaning. Then it added something worse for Uber. In 2019, a federal appeals court in Blair v. Rent-A-Center had read similar severance language to mean the entire cause of action. Uber wrote its 2023 terms against that backdrop, so it was on notice that “claim” was “at best, a problematic word” for splitting a case.

Ambiguity triggered California’s contra proferentem rule (Civil Code section 1654), which reads unclear contract language against whoever wrote it. The rule carries extra force in contracts of adhesion, the take-it-or-leave-it forms consumers accept without negotiating.

Federal Arbitration Law Didn’t Save Uber

Uber argued that the Federal Arbitration Act preempts (overrides) that rule and requires courts to resolve doubts in favor of arbitration. The court disagreed. As it read Lamps Plus, the U.S. Supreme Court blocked the drafter rule there only because it would have forced class arbitration on a party that never agreed to it. Here the rule cuts the other way, keeping consumers out of arbitration they never clearly accepted. Consent anchors federal arbitration law, so the court found no conflict, and both causes of action stay in court.

What This Means for Businesses with Online Terms

If your terms keep individual relief in arbitration while carving out public injunction requests, read the fallback language now. If it says “claims,” a California court may hand the whole cause of action to a judge. Blair itself recognized that parties can split the work, with an arbitrator deciding liability first and a court handling only the public injunction. They just have to say so clearly. Draft in terms of remedies, and spell out which forum decides what.

Getting it wrong costs time, too. Uber spent about sixteen months on appeal only to land back in court.

Bottom Line

Your arbitration agreement is only as strong as its weakest fallback clause. California courts read ambiguous consumer terms against the company that drafted them, and Bogguess holds that federal arbitration law doesn’t override that rule when applying it protects consent. A one-word fix costs almost nothing today. A class action in court costs a great deal more.

Horst Legal Counsel works with businesses on arbitration enforceability and business litigation. If you’d like to know how your terms of service hold up under Bogguess, we’re glad to take a look. Contact us here.

The post One Word in Your Arbitration Severability Clause Can Keep a Class Action in Court appeared first on Horst Legal Counsel.

]]>